In late December 2008, I purchased a 3 pack of LED light bulbs from Sam’s Club. While the bulbs were expensive, topping out a $15 for the 3 pack, I figured that buying one pack as a test would be a reasonable expense.
The bulbs advertised that they use 10% of the electricity of a normal incandescent bulb. The bulbs I bought were for a candelabra light, so I unfortunately wasn’t able to test that claim using the Kill-A-Watt. The candelabra that I would be putting the bulbs in had room for 6 bulbs, so I would be replacing 3 of those with the new LED lights.
The first thing that I noticed after installing them was that these bulbs were no where as bright as the incandescents they were replacing. Since I was only replacing three bulbs out of six, I was able to get away with it. However, if I had bought six bulbs, I’m sure that they would not have had produced enough light to be a practical replacement.
The bulbs actually didn’t look too bad. Unlike some of the florescent bulbs that I’ve tried, these bulbs didn’t look too cheesy in the candelabra.
The bad news is that within 3 weeks of installation, the bulbs started to die (unfortunately, I can’t identify a specific date because the bulbs are so dim that I may not have noticed that one of them had died right away). After the first bulb stopped working, I emailed the manufacturer, Lights of America to see if I could get a replacement. That was on February 6th, and as of March 2nd, I still have not received a response.
The remaining two bulbs both died within three weeks of the first failure.
As far as electricity savings are concerned, my electric bill did decrease about 10% in the given time frame, however, I had also purchased a new, more efficient, refrigerator which is probably more responsible for the decrease than the LEDs bulbs.
Given this experience, I cannot recommend these LED bulbs at this time. They just aren’t durable enough or pump out enough light.
Disclaimer: I did install the lights on a lighting fixture that is controlled by a dimmer switch. However, the dimmer control is incorporated into the light switch (not a circular knob) and is left on “full” at all times. The LED light packaging states that they do not recommend installing the lights on a dimmer circuit. If someone has had better luck with these LED lights from Sam’s Club, please post in the comments.